This is just a vent, nothing more. If you're feeling offended, please don't be. I hold no hard feelings toward anyone. This isn't pointed at anyone and if your feelings are different, that's great! I rejoice in our differences of opinion!
One of the little things that bugs me is Mother's Day in the church. This has nothing to do with me being or not being a mother, nor is it meant to insult any of the wonderful, hard-working mothers out there. My issue here is plainly how we treat it within the church.
Every Mother's Day something is handed out to the "adult women" or "women 18 and up". I know, "we all have the potential to become mothers" and "we are all mothers in our own way" (these things are said every year). That being said, it is Mother's Day, not Mothers' Day, not Women's Day (March 8) or Groundhog Day. (I complained about that one too, maybe I just have an issue with holidays in general.)
In 1912, Anna Jarvis trademarked the phrases "second Sunday in May" and "Mother's Day", and created the Mother's Day International Association.Mother's Day is a day set aside to celebrate the women who raised (and are still raising) us as well as the women who gave birth to us. For some of us this is the same person, for some it is not. Yes, all of the women in the world are wonderful. Yes, different people can be our "mothers" at different times and in different ways. Every woman (and man) influences every person around them, whether they want to or not. I'm not saying that women aren't great or that we shouldn't tell women that we appreciate how they mold and influence our lives.
"She was specific about the location of the apostrophe; it was to be a singular possessive, for each family to honour their mother, not a plural possessive commemorating all mothers in the world." (emphasis added)
What I am saying is: I do not feel that gifts should be given to all of the women at church. I don't believe gifts should be given at all, from the church. I feel that this is yet another holiday that has gone too commercialized and we look for the easiest way to get out of doing something about it.
Go up to Sister Jones and tell her you love her singing.
Go to Sister Smith and thank her for helping you with your children when your husband is on the stand.
Bishops, if you really want to thank the women, stand at the back doors as we exit and tell us what you're thankful for.
I loved my gift from my loving husband who calls me the "mother of the house" and "mother in training". I love, even more, that he took the time to tell me why he was giving a gift to someone who hasn't born children on Mother's Day. (BTW he got me a spoon full of sugar to keep me from being lonely while he's gone this week)

Okay, I hope that all made sense. I'm done ranting now, so I'll conclude with something I read on bycommonconsent.com/ today. I felt it emphasizes my feelings of Mother's Day being commercialized within the church when we can read this and answer without a second thought to what he's talking about.
Post-Mother’s Day Meeting Debrief May 11, 2009 — Scott B
A few simple questions for consideration and discussion regarding your ward’s Mother’s Day festivities:
1. Priesthood Choir or Primary Choir?
2. Flowers or Cookies?
3. Oh, My Father, or Love at Home?
4. Old People or Young People?
5. Spiritual Feast or Cringe-Fest?
For fun, go ahead and let me know your answers!
9 comments:
I also think it's a little weird that they give something at mother's day. With that being said. . . I enjoyed eating my chocolate. I'll never turn down chocolate. :-)
Hello Iversons! I'm so glad I stumbled upon your blog. Hope everything is going well for you guys! Love you both.
Heather! Does that mean you have one too? We miss our triple-date nights and think of you every week! Hope you're doing well, as well!
Hey Julianna!
* No choir at all
* Dove Candy bars....delicious- that were handed out when we walked in so no one had to stand up and feel awkward
* Grandparents spoke...it was great
* Oh my Father
* Can't remember the other question :)
I've had my share of annoyed Mother's Days that's for sure, some where I didn't even want to go to church. It is a hard day for so many so I like when it's acknowledged but not made into a huge party at church.
Sure love ya!
I think the best "gift" we could get would be to have the priesthood be in charge of the lessons for the day so we did not have the stress of a normal hectic Sunday! For me, Mother's Day seems crazier than most Sundays and I go home with a headache (especially in Primary where we do crafts for mom). I do like the hear the kids sing, but the men would have a greater impact because we hardly ever hear them sing. I would like 1 youth speaker and 2 older speakers to get different perspectives of motherhood.I like both songs and don't have a preference and it would be nice to have a spiritual feast. No need for flower or cookie. Just my thoughts, love your posts that make you think!
Hi Julianna! I read this post and thought I'd offer my two cents. I know that I am a mother and had a great mother, and perhaps that influences my perspective, but I've thought a lot about your post and just wanted to share my thoughts with you.
I am very grateful that the church recognizes Mother's Day. I'm sure you are very correct about the origin of Mother's Day and it's original meaning and intention. But, "the church" doesn't give gifts to women. Individual wards do. That's why there is a variation to what I got versus what you or Kristin Walburger got! I got a Hershey's Milk Chocolate bar wrapped with a paper that reads: "Here's wishing you a Mother's Day that's filled with every pleasure, and a future that's as happy as the memories you treasure!" The paper is signed from my ward, not the church. I believe there's a big difference.
Bishops merely want to be as sensitive as they can to all women of the ward. Some people did not have wonderful mothers, or any mother at all. Some women cannot bear children. Imagine how it would look if only women who have born children were recognized on Mother's Day? What if the bishop only offered compliments to those women? Imagine how many hurt feelings there would be.
What if the Bishops of individual wards chose not to recognize Mother's Day at ALL! What if it was a church-wide directive stating that to avoid being insensitive to child-less women, Mother's Day would not be recognized? I believe that this would just fuel the fire already in existence that the Mormon church demeans women. Women aren't important to Mormon people. ETC.
The fact of the matter is that each ward or branch is composed of a bishop/branch leader, his wife, and his councilors with their wives. Then there are individual families, and together they all make up a ward family. What better time is there to celebrate the sacredness of Womanhood than on Mother's Day--always a Sunday. The bishop, as the head of his ward family, has the chance to let the women (yes, all mother's in their own way) of his ward know that he recognizes and values them for their divine nature, influence, and potential.
It is most practical and fair for the bishopric to offer the same token of appreciation to every woman, instead of spending an enormous amount of their already limited time thinking of individual things to say to each woman. Let their own families do that.
Besides, don't you think that if the behavior of the "church" on Mother's Day was inappropriate, the Prophet would say or do something about it? Since he hasn't, I'd say that everything is going as well as it could.
All-in-all, it's just an awkward situation. You can't please everyone. Somewhere, someone will be bothered about something. I'm just glad that my ward, and the wards of those I care about chooses to honor and recognize the Women of their ward family on Mother's Day.
Please know that I mean no offense to you. I can see your point. I think it's a delicate situation that the wards are doing their best with.
BTW, it was great seeing you at Women's Conference! Love Ya!
Of course I want to see you!!! We have already decided to make time to see you guys and Aaron was going to talk to Phil about it, but he is just a man after all... He can only be expected to remember to do so many things every day... Like 1.
I heard somethingreally nice about Mother's Day. I think it should be called "Women's Day" Doesn't that sound so much better?
Love you guys!
Personally....
1. BOTH... I love when the Priesthood Sings to the ward. The strength in their voices makes my heart skip a beat, and the Primary Children make me cry so bring BOTH on!
2. Cookies!!!!... or chocolate or candy of ANY sort... I will kill the flower you give me, and I can't eat it so yeah...
3. Love at Home, only because it is a favorite of mine.
4. I like old and young perspective. I would like to get a few Primary kids up there too to give their thoughts on mothers... they always say funny things. Then get the angry teenagers, the newlyweds, the new struggling parents, the ones with teeneagers, and the and old parents, then grandparents... whoever has insight on motherhood...
5. The last one really depends on the person and the feelings they are bringing, but I personally thed to enjoy the spiritual feast, but our ideas of "spiritual feast" might differ.
I have always enjoyed Mother's Day. It was SO much easier to enjoy when I was just thanking MY mother for what she had done for me. And then when I was able to add to that list with my MIL, and being thankful for the Man she raised. Once I became a mother, it was nice that my ward recognized the "daily grind" that is my life. There are Sundays I am not sure WHAT was going on at church... it is NOT easy even getting myself there, and I often wonder who would really miss me if I did not come with my rowdy kids??? Then I remind myself that I need the church to help me be a better mother, and I appreciate the Ward being thankful for me, and giving me a little gift for my hard work. I don't think they need to give the "Mothers" gifts, but It feels good that they took the time to thank us for the job we are doing at home.
I can see the whole "WHY GIFT'S THING?" but I am with Nichole... I'll never turn down chocolate! ~:)
Post a Comment